Caldwell Seafood Restaurant – Stunningly Good
Our Specialties
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail 18
Four jumbo gulf shrimp served with mode made cocktail sauce.
-
Hotsy Totsy Shrimp 19
Small Fried Shrimp tossed in a Spicy Marinara Sauce.
-
Seafood Salad 22
Calamari, shrimp, octopus, scungili, vinegar peppers, celery, olives, lemon & oil dressing.
-
Shrimp Gorgonzola (6) 34
large gulf shrimp and a creamy gorgonzola sauce served over fresh white and green pasta.
-
Crab Cakes (2) 38
made of jumbo lump crabmeat baked, tartar sauce with steamed broccoli.
-
King Crab Legs MP
steamed, served with drawn butter and steamed broccoli.


A restaurant where product quality and chef expertise transform into true artistry. Discover the perfect blend of fresh ingredients

Finest Seafood & Cozy Atmosphere
We have the widest variety and the freshest seafood in the local area. We offer a marketplace so you can prepare your own seafood and offer a wide range of delicious meals from our menu if you want us to do the cooking for you!


Learn about the Caldwell dining experience

From Ocean to Plate
We source premium seafood daily, ensuring the highest quality in every dish.

Culinary Excellence
Our chefs bring artistry and technique, blending tradition with innovation.

Unparalleled Ambiance
Whether dining in or shopping at our seafood market, experience an atmosphere of sophistication and warmth.


Caldwell Marketplace
Caldwell Seafood’s marketplace is a vibrant and bustling hub for fresh, high-quality seafood. Picture a bright, airy space where the salty ocean breeze seems to waft through the doors, accompanied by the enticing aroma of freshly caught fish. The marketplace features a stunning array of seafood options, from glistening fillets of salmon and tuna to succulent shellfish like shrimp, crab, and oysters.
Stalls are manned by knowledgeable staff who are passionate about seafood, ready to share cooking tips and recipes. The decor blends nautical elements with a modern touch, featuring wooden accents, marine-themed artwork, and clean, inviting displays that highlight the freshness of the products.
Sustainable sourcing is a key focus, with partnerships with local fishermen and eco-friendly practices emphasized throughout the marketplace. Customers can also find a selection of gourmet sauces, seasonings, and cooking tools to complement their seafood selections, making it a one-stop shop for seafood lovers.
Overall, your marketplace is not just a place to buy seafood; it’s an experience that celebrates the ocean’s bounty and the joy of cooking with fresh ingredients!

Our seafood is picked up daily at 3 AM from the freshest seaport in Hunts Point, NY.
Our Customer Say




Market Hours
Tue - Sat
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday
10:00 AM - 03:00 PM
Monday
CLOSED
Restaurant Hours
Tue - Sat
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Mon - Sun
CLOSED
Have Questions?
Reach out to us for reservations, special orders, or catering inquiries.